Posts tagged as:

Girl Scout

The Girl Scouts have been busy with their organizational re-branding efforts. With the start of the 2010 Cookie Season, they have a new branding campaign specifically designed to make Girl Scout cookies meaningful.

IMG_1046.JPGBack when I wrote the post Wal-Mart Knocks Off the Girl Scouts, about Walmart entering into competition with the Girls Scouts on their iconic Thin Mint cookies, I received scads of angry comments about the prices of Girl Scout cookies. I also got many snarky thank yous for letting people know that reasonably good facsimiles of Girl Scouts’ Thin Mints were available as part of Walmart’s ‘Great Value’ private label offerings.

Beyond the unnecessary anger these comments reflected, they did point out a big problem for the Girls Scouts and their cookies– people had started to treat the Girl Scouts’ Thin Mints like regular, ordinary cookies.

Girl Scout cookies, to these readers, were not something special that commanded a high price point or that made a contribution to anything but your waist measurements.

Now, the Girl Scouts themselves are taking the lead in getting their message out. The Girl Scouts have launched a cookie based branding campaign:

“Every Cookie Has a Mission:
To Help Girls Do Great Things”

The campaign includes a few terrific videos, some collateral material (for putting stories into local newspapers) and a significant effort to promote a consistent message. I have no inside information about the campaign per se, but my online searching has shown me that the message is widespread and consistent across regional and local Girl Scouts’ web & print presentations.

We can’t tell yet whether the cookie videos will really “go viral” in the true sense of the term. But, the “Every Cookie Has a Mission” videos are certainly charming, inspiring and to the point.

Take a look at this Cookie video yourself (it’s only 30 seconds long).

The Girls Scouts do need to raise their profile, (re)educate the community about the work the Girl Scouts themselves do, and enducate the community about what Girl Scouting offers to girls and to the larger community.

All of these messages should help the public understand why they should support the Girl Scouts.

Cookies + Mission = Great Branding

Attaching the “Mission” to the cookies themselves is terrific strategy. Girl Scout Cookies, and Thin Mints in particular, have their own cultural capital and celebrity. With the additional branding efforts, the Cookies that Have a Mission communication the meaning of  not only the iconic symbol of the Girl Scouts, or the chief fundraiser for the Girl Scouts, but also the meaning of the Girl Scouts themselves.IMG_0299.JPG

Instead of just having a Thin Mint cookie, you can have a part in the Girl Scouts’ mission to teach leadership skills, teach business skills, and help girls contribute to their communities.

An added benefit? Customers can focus on the mission of the cookies, and not their cost or their calorie counts.

Now, when customers see that the ‘real’ Thin Mints cost 25% more than the national brand ones (e.g., Keebler’s) and 35% more than the Walmart private label ones, they might understand that the price is related not just to the cookie, but to the meaning behind the cookie, to the values the cookie represents, to the activities the cookies support.

After watching this video, do you think you’ll be more inclined to buy Girl Scout cookies?

Because, you know, you wouldn’t be buying a chocolate wafer with a melty mint coating. You’d be buying a Cookie That Has a Mission.  So be prepared, and plan to buy lots of cookies.

Here’s the extended, more poignant version, “What Can A Cookie Do?” (1.25 secs)

If you're interested in this issue, please subscribe to my RSS feed. Or, use the blue box (upper right) to get an emailed update. Join the conversation below...

{ 0 comments }

Good news for you and your Thin Mint Addiction!

The Girl Scouts are making it easy to find out where those dang cookies are being sold!

(Now I don’t have to drive to Walmart and get the cheaper but less meaningful generic imitations!)

The Girl Scouts have an online cookie locator– just type in your zip code and (in most cases) you get all you need to know to fulfill your cookie cravings.online cookie.jpg

This is a great innovation, since it’s much easier to buy cookies when you know when and where they’ll be available, right?

But there is one interesting tweak with the Girls Scouts’ online sale program — you can’t actually “buy” the cookies with a few mouse clicks.

You can let your local Girl Scouts know that you want to but cookies, and in some areas you can place an order, but in all cases an actual Girl Scout has to deliver the cookies to you and collect your payment.

Obviously, this extra step adds ‘friction’ to the sales process, and may deter some customers from buying cookies.

Is it smart for the Girl Scouts to have this limitation on their cookie e-commerce?

Absolutely. This may be a little annoyance for the cookie buyer who wants a quick fix. BUT, this obstacle serves an important purpose.

By having the cookies delivered by actual Girl Scouts, this step in the sales process –

  1. Reminds buyers that there are actual Girl Scouts connected to the cookies. These are Cookies with a Mission, sold by Girls who are doing Great Things.
  2. Allows buyers to meet a few Girl Scouts in their town. Heck, they may even recognize these girls as neighbors– supporting a sense of community.
  3. Allows buyers and Girl Scouts a chance to talk about Scouting, about the girls’ troop’s plans for the money and/or their activities in the community.
  4. Keeps the girls themselves actively involved in the sales process, so that they keep learning the right lessons about business.

Girl Scout Cookie Sales exist for several reasons, only one of which is fundraising.

As we discovered in the responses to my posts about Girl Scout Cookies, Walmart, and social media, there is a great deal of misunderstanding, as well as general lack of understanding, about how cookie sales support the Girl Scouts. (I’ll address these issues in some upcoming posts. )

This little tweak in the online-assisted Girl Scout Cookie Sales process might look like it is limiting the number of cookies the Girl Scouts might sell — but it also makes sure that the cookie sales support the Girl Scouts’ overall brand. This may cost them a little in lost sales, but it contributes to the overall program for rebranding the Girl Scouts and reinforcing their mission.

I can’t imagine that anyone who loves authentic Thin Mints, or authentic organizations, will be deterred by a little face-to-face brandbuilding, do you?

[Fortunately or unfortunately, the specifics & ease of these online-assisted sales will vary with your Girl Scout Council (the region assigned by your zip code). Some Councils ask you to enter your email and then have a particular troop contact you. Other regions just have a landing page with basic info about the sale program. My own Council has an inert and not-very-helpful landing page. And yes, I have already sent them an email with suggestions on how to improve it quickly. We'll see how they respond.]

{ 0 comments }

Can Walmart Earn the Girl Scouts’ Good Citizenship Award?

August 14, 2009

You don’t earn a merit badge for Good Citizenship by picking on the Girl Scouts. But what if Wal-mart wanted to?
Commenters here and on other blogs that picked up my story that Wal-mart has chosen to compete with the Girl Scouts by knocking off the Girls Scouts’ two most popular cookies have criticized Wal-mart for [...]

Read the full article →

Wal-Mart Knocks Off the Girl Scouts

August 3, 2009

(Welcome MacLeans Readers… Please join the conversation! )
Just when you think your opinion about Wal-mart might be changing…
Just when you think that maybe, just maybe, Wal-mart was learning to be a better citizen…
Wal-mart turns around and does something really … despicable.
It’s not discriminating against women, strong-arming suppliers, polluting neighborhoods or racing to the bottom [...]

Read the full article →