Tools for Authentic Organizations: Dotmocracy

by cv harquail on March 17, 2023

Originally posted March 23, 2009

The end of “business as usual”

Please, let us be coming to the end of “business as usual”. Conversations about whether MBA programs caused the financial crisis and what the future of capitalism should be suggest that ways of doing business that have long been seen as acceptable and even admirable are now being revealed as economically, socially and ecologically destructive. Hasn’t this economic crisis lead you to doubt whether “business as usual” is something we really want to recover? I, for one, don’t think that business as usual is worth saving.

Welcome “progressive organizational movements”

In spite of all the bad news, I’m becoming more optimistic that positive change may will occur, because I’m seeing all around us a range of (what I call) progressive organizational movements. Progressive organizational movements are initiatives that aim to create social and economic change simultaneously, through for-purpose business, through nonprofit initiatives and/or through political initiatives.

When I think about the macro-dynamics of organizations that are subtly and radically different working to improve our economic, social, political, and natural world, there really is change afoot. Yet, the organization scholar in me wonders about the relationship between the ends: social transformation, and the means: the organizational systems and tools that will create the organizations that will lead these changes.

Audre Lorde’s Change Leadership Advice

As Audre Lord memorably reminds anyone who ever takes a women’s studies class,

The master’s tools will never dismantle the master’s house.

The master’s tools won’t help us build authentic organizations, either. So now we need to ask:

  1. What tools will progressive organizations use to create the changes we need to see in our world?
  2. What tools can organizations use so that they simultaneously move towards their goals and act now on their principles?
  3. Where can progressive organizations find tools that express their values?

Venezuela dotmocracy.jpegProgressive organizations, organizations with a change-oriented purpose, need to put their values into practice as they go about creating change. Otherwise, they will not act authentically and they will reduce their own power.

Every organization devoted to change needs to be built with new “tools” and I’m not just talking about Web 2.0 tools. I’m thinking about decision making tools, information sharing tools, coordination tools, feedback systems, tracking tools, and tools for celebration. Cellar to roof.

Finding alternative tools

Thus motivated, I’ve begun a quiet quest for new, alternative tools. When I say new , I don’t mean taking popular tools like GTD and scaling them up to the organizational level. When I say alternative , I’m not looking for tools that are built on conventional assumptions about relationships between people or conventional assumptions about what good “control and coordination” look like.What is Dotmocracy? | Dotmocracy_1237827403226.jpeg

I’m thinking alternative in that these tools start from a different premise about who we are and why we are together. I’m looking for tools that will support businesses and organizations that exist for something beyond profit, and that want to model right now the changes they seek. Still with me?

Dotmocracy, a little example of a big change

So, last week, when blogging friend Easton Ellsworth was looking for ideas about how to get tons of people involved in a cause, I sent him to this site: Dotmocracy.

Dotmocracy is a deceptively simple , easy way for a group of people to generate ideas and evaluate options. On the website is quick explaination of the process as well as manuals and forms for putting the process to work in your organization.

As described by Jason Diceman, an activist who has codified the advanced form of Dotmocracy: [click to continue…]

{ Comments on this entry are closed }

Originally posted 4/14/2009

I just got done commenting on the blog of my colleague and blogging buddy Michael Roberto, a strategy professor at Bryant University. Michael blogged today about his concern that Americans (and by extension, students in the Business Schools where many of us teach) have lost faith in Capitalism.

Michael’s answer to this problem, in so many words, is that

“As educators, we should never flinch from teaching that capitalism is far superior to socialism, while acknowledging that people of different political affiliations may have different views on the form of capitalism that should be employed.”

Should I have been surprised to find myself writing 300+ words in reply?

Probably not. I know my views on Capitalism (and by extension, democratic socialism) are not as common in the business schools where I have learned and taught as they are in the political science and philosophy departments where my views were first formed.

Moreover, I recognize that I was probably the only Darden faculty member ever to receive anonymous feedback from a student that “People who don’t believe in Capitalism shouldn’t be allowed to teach in a business school.”

Apparently being married to a Harvard MBA, getting a 4.0 in my MBA Finance course, having a PhD from a Business School, owning stocks and amassing property wasn’t enough to establish my street cred as a believer in Capitalism. Which is, in the end, fine with me. Why? Because —

It’s less important to be a believer than it is to be someone who understands.

And, it is less important to accept what Capitalism as practice has to offer us, than it is to consider how to adjust, reform, and apply Capitalism to make the world a better place.

I’m pasting most of Michael’s post, as well as my reply, below, for your enjoyment. Please do check out Michael’s blog directly… not because I agree with him most of the time (I generally do) but also because he has useful insights on a wide range of business & strategy issues.

I’d love your thoughts on these issues… if you share them in the Comments, below, I’ll incorporate them in my upcoming discussions of Progressive Organizational Movements… [click to continue…]

{ Comments on this entry are closed }

How Generosity At Work Saved a Local Business

April 26, 2016

Tweet  ~ crossposted from cvharquail.com ~ A story from my own hometown… When I was getting my start-of-the-semester haircut in February, I was surprised to see Hannah, the woman who cuts my teenagers’ hair, working in the hair salon I go to. Hannah normally works at Parlor, which has a hipster clientele. Yet here she […]

Read the full article →

Come With Me To a New Place on the Interwebz!

March 24, 2016

Tweet Thank you SO much for being a longtime reader of AuthenticOrganizations! It’s meant a lot to me to know that there have been people on the other end of these ideas. Not just the visitors who click on over from Twitter, LinkedIn, or a guest post … but also the nearly 500 of you […]

Read the full article →

3 Ways Etsy’s Parental Leave Policy Demonstrates Generosity At Work

March 23, 2016

Tweet For so many reasons, Etsy has been one of my leading examples of companies practicing Generosity At Work.  I rely on Etsy’s Code As Craft initiative to illustrate the strategy of Opening Your Learning, but that’s only one way that Etsy demonstrates an expanded culture of generosity. Etsy uses each of the five higher-level […]

Read the full article →

Defining Your Business’s Success Using Net Positive Value

February 4, 2016

Tweet Here’s an excerpt from the introduction to Generosity At Work that defines a concept that’s critical for assessing the impact of your business. Let me know what you think! Defining Net Positive Value Self-centered business care whether their own bottom line is growing.  Generous businesses care about their own growth at the same time […]

Read the full article →

Generous Products: How Products Do What They Do, as a form of Generosity

January 7, 2016

Tweet I’m “working out loud in public” with a rangy, rambling first draft. What I’m working to understand, with this draft, is how to explain ‘generous products’, and how to link ideas about generous products to current conversations about product design. This is a small piece of the puzzle, focused on how products themselves might be […]

Read the full article →

Campfire Generosity

December 21, 2015

Tweet A little story I’m using to illustrate Generosity At Work — Three cowhands are setting up camp on a chilly night. While one builds the campfire and the second gets water for the horses, the third takes command of the saddles. He drags each one to the far side of the fire pit, lines them up […]

Read the full article →

What Generosity At Work Looks Like: Subway Version

November 20, 2015

Tweet @Brian_Ashcraft of Kotaku  shared this gif of two commuters who, somewhat accidentally, illustrate how one business can be generous with another while becoming stronger itself.   The tall fellow ends up with a hand on each strap, making his own stance more sturdy. The shorter guy gets something to hold that he can actually […]

Read the full article →

Why We Should Be Using Feminism At Work

May 20, 2015

Tweet I wrote this explanation of Feminism at Work back in Feb of 2013.  In advance of our panel at In Good Company on June 1, I’m reposting it as pre-reading for folks who’ll be attending. Want to join us? Sign up here: Everyday Leadership for Women Entrepreneurs It’s time to use the f-word at work. […]

Read the full article →